Build Your Dream MLB Team and We'll Tell You Which Baseball Legend You Are

By: Gavin Thagard
Estimated Completion Time
3 min
Build Your Dream MLB Team and We'll Tell You Which Baseball Legend You Are
Image: Hill Street Studios LLC/DigitalVision/Getty Images

About This Quiz

It's a warm Sunday in the spring, your grandpa is on the couch, the baseball game is blaring on the television, and you are looking through your baseball cards wondering which of the legendary baseball players from the past you would be. Are you the team captain who led your team to multiple championships? Are you the heavy hitter who blasted home runs out of the stadium game after game? Maybe you are the all-around athlete who fans marvel to watch anytime they take the field. 

Deep down, every MLB fan has a baseball legend calling out to them. These baseball legends are descriptions of character and action. They can tell you not only what kind of player but what kind of person you are in your core, how you would fare in the face of competition, and which type of attributes you carry around in your day to day life. 

How can an MLB roster tell you which baseball legend you are, though? Here's your chance to find out. Put together your fantasy roster, and we will tell you which baseball legend you are. Get started and find out if you're a heavy hitter, an All-Star pitcher or a combination of it all. 

Which Hall of Fame slugger would you want on your team?
Hank Aaron
Mickey Mantle
Carl Yastrzemski
Stan Musial
Who would you take off of the current Red Sox roster?
J.D. Martinez
Mookie Betts
Jackie Bradley Jr.
David Brice
These former pitchers knew how to strike batters out. Which one would you take?
Pedro Martinez
Nolan Ryan
Randy Johnson
Cy Young

Advertisement

Which of these 2018 home run leaders do you want to add to your team?
Mike Trout
Joey Gallo
Khris Davis
J.D. Martinez
Which former Rookie of the Year are you taking?
Cal Ripken
Mark McGwire
Pete Rose
Tom Seaver
The Dodgers made it to the World Series in 2018. Who would you take from their roster?
Yasiel Puig
Justin Turner
Matt Kemp
Clayton Kershaw

Advertisement

These defenders guarded first base. Which would you take?
Albert Pujols
David Ortiz
Lou Gehrig
Frank Thomas
Which of these current catchers would you add to your team?
Gary Sanchez
Buster Posey
Salvador Perez
J.T. Realmuto
These Yankees had their number retired. Which of them do you want on your team?
Ron Guidry
Joe DiMaggio
Derek Jeter
Mickey Mantle

Advertisement

These hitters knew how to get on base. Which one are you adding to your team?
Stan Musial
Hank Aaron
Ty Cobb
Pete Rose
Which of these current Indians players do you want on your team?
Jose Ramirez
Francisco Lindor
Michael Brantley
Corey Kluber
These players spent their entire career with one team. Which do you want?
Ernie Banks
Cal Ripken Jr.
Roberto Clemente
Joe DiMaggio

Advertisement

Of these all-time great shortstops, who would you take?
Derek Jeter
Ernie Banks
Honus Wagner
Ozzie Smith
These players traveled from team to team throughout their career. Which of them do you want on your roster?
Reggie Jackson
Rickey Henderson
Frank Robinson
Nolan Ryan
Which of these former Cy Young winners would you take?
Roger Clemens
Randy Johnson
Roy Halladay
Sandy Koufax

Advertisement

These players set the home run bar higher and higher. Which one would you take?
Sammy Sosa
Barry Bonds
Mark McGwire
Hank Aaron
Of these all-time great outfielders, who are you taking on your team?
Joe DiMaggio
Ty Cobb
Ken Griffey Jr.
Ichiro Suzuki
Which MLB player from the '70s are you taking?
Joe Morgan
Reggie Jackson
Mike Schmidt
Tom Seaver

Advertisement

These players knew how to score runs. Which one do you want on your roster?
Tris Speaker
Pete Rose
Rickey Henderson
Lou Gehrig
Which Yankees player from the 2018 roster do you want on your team?
Giancarlo Stanton
Didi Gregorius
Aaron Judge
CC Sabathia
Which of these players with over 18 All-Star appearances do you want on your team?
Stan Musial
Hank Aaron
Cal Ripken Jr.
Carl Yastrzemski

Advertisement

These players dominated the 1930s. Which one would you put on your team?
Lefty Grove
Bill Dickey
Lou Gehrig
Charlie Gehringer
Of these legendary catchers, which would you put on your roster?
Yogi Berra
Johnny Bench
Carlton Fisk
Gary Carter
From these current pitchers, who are you adding to your team?
Corey Kluber
Max Scherzer
Chris Sale
Clayton Kershaw

Advertisement

Which All-Star from the '80s would you want on your team?
Dwight Gooden
Mike Schmidt
Lou Whitaker
Robin Yount
Despite the controversy surrounding these players, which one would you want on your team?
Barry Bonds
Pete Rose
"Shoeless" Joe Jackson
Mark McGwire
These are some of the most popular players of the '60s. Which one would you put on your team?
Juan Marichal
Bob Gibson
Frank Robinson
Roberto Clemente

Advertisement

Which of the top third baseman from 2018 would you want?
Nolan Arenado
Jose Ramirez
Josh Donaldson
Kris Bryant
These were the top pitchers of the '90s. Which one do you want on your team?
Curt Schilling
Pedro Martinez
Randy Johnson
Roger Clemens
The live-ball era started in the 1920s, which player do you want from that era?
Lou Gehrig
Rogers Hornsby
Tris Speaker
Grover Cleveland Alexander

Advertisement

You Got: