Order a Bunch of Food From Shake Shack and We'll Guess Your Secret Fetish

By: Jennifer Post
Estimated Completion Time
5 min
Order a Bunch of Food From Shake Shack and We'll Guess Your Secret Fetish
Image: Wiki Commons by m01229

About This Quiz

Shake Shack originated in New York City, where it first opened in 2010 but has since expanded to many locations on the East Coast, 208 of them to be exact. It's categorized as a fast-casual restaurant, but it doesn't feel like any other fast casual place. The quality of the ingredients they use is of a higher caliber than other burger joints, and it really shows in the flavor of the food. They pride themselves on having cage-free eggs, free-range chicken and non-GMO burger buns. All of that is what sets them apart from other places. If you're not on the East Coast of the United States, they also have many international locations. 

The creation of Shake Shack was due to the revitalization of Madison Square Park and spearheaded by restauranteur Danny Meyer. Fun fact! It was never meant to be a chain. But like anything as delicious and high quality as Shake Shack comes along, more people are going to want to be able to experience it. Because sales were growing so rapidly, they decided to open up more locations. Since then, the menu has grown as have their collaborations with local artisans to make things like a signature chocolate bar. 

Food like this can be a really eye-opening experience for diners. Don't think so? Order up a bunch of food from Shake Shack, and we'll guess the fetish you've been trying to keep secret!

Would you order just the good old Shack Burger?
All day every day
I'd need more food than that.
Totally!
Probably the double
Which Shack dog sounds the best to you out of all the options?
Hot dog with Shack cheese sauce
Chicken dog
I'll take the Shack-cago dog with all the fixings.
I don't love hot dogs.
Are the regular fries or cheese fries more your style?
Cheese fries hands down
I'll take any kind of fry.
Probably the cheese fries but cheese on the side
Fries are too salty.

Advertisement

Let's get down to business. Which shake are you getting from the shack?
OMG, caramel
Black and white malt shake
Classic chocolate
Coffee for me!
Is there another ice cream treat you want more than a milkshake?
Chocolate custard
A concrete
Root beer float
I'm just in it for the milkshakes.
Do you order a milkshake mostly so you have something to dip your fries into?
I just really love milkshakes.
Obviously
Ew!
I like sipping on them.

Advertisement

If you were having a party catered by Shake Shack, what would you order the most of?
Fries
Shack sauce
Milkshakes
I'd just get like three of everything.
Do you know Shake Shack has breakfast?
What now?!
I do and it's delicious.
They should stick to burgers.
No, but I'd love to try it.
Which menu item is the best to take home and eat on the couch in front of the TV?
Chick'n Shack
Double Shack burger
Cheese dog
The largest concrete they'll sell me

Advertisement

Which breakfast item would you choose if you stopped by on your way to work?
Sausage egg and cheese
Bacon egg and cheese
Just a coffee
Plain egg and cheese and orange juice
What's the best mix-in for a blended ice cream treat at Shake Shack?
Hazelnut Brown Butter Streusel
Marshmallow sauce and crispy crunchies
Cinnamon fudge sauce
Chocolate truffle cookie dough
With the Shack-cago dog, are there any toppings you're leaving off?
Sport pepper because I have no idea what that is.
Cucumbers don't belong on hot dogs.
I'll take it all!
No mustard, please

Advertisement

There's more than just soft drinks at this fine establishment. Which drink refreshes your palate?
Half lemonade, half iced tea
Draft root beer
Shack-made lemonade
Freshly brewed iced tea
Which secret menu item are you taking to work for lunch and hopefully not eating at 10 a.m.?
Cheese fries with Shack sauce
Peanut butter bacon cheeseburger
Protein style burger
Quad burger
Which menu item is the best to take on a summer picnic?
Fries and a milkshake
Burger and lemonade
Concrete and fries
Bacon cheeseburger and a hot dog

Advertisement

If it was someone's first experience with Shake Shack and they asked you for a recommendation, what would you suggest they start out with?
Can't go wrong with a single Shack burger
A classic meal of cheeseburger, fries and a shake
Literally anything
Maybe a burger and hot dog to be safe
Do you need anything to be gluten free?
I hope the fries are.
The bun needs to be.
Nope, I can eat anything.
Not need, but I might order it
Do you take your burger with lettuce and tomato?
And onion!
No tomato
I just want a cheeseburger on a bun.
I take it with everything on it.

Advertisement

Are you getting anything special put on your burger?
Just cheese
All the Shack Sauce
Bacon
Mushrooms
What's the best thing about the ingredients Shake Shack uses?
They're mostly free range.
Non-GMO
They're delicious.
They put a lot of care in their food.
You're ordering up a custard, but it needs a little something more. Which sauce is going on top?
Hot fudge for sure
Caramel sauce is way better.
I want cookie pieces.
Both!

Advertisement

Fries are hot, crispy, salty and delicious on their own, but which dipping sauce takes them to a new level?
Ketchup
Shack sauce
Cheese sauce
Milkshake
Which float flavor goes the best with a classic Shack burger?
Root beer
Creamsicle
Purple cow!
I don't get the appeal of ice cream floats.
Your dog has joined you in this feast! What menu item are you ordering for your pup?
Just a water bowl
A Pooch-ini
ShackBurger dog biscuits
I don't bring my dog to restaurants.

Advertisement

Out of all the menu items, which one do you keep going back to time and time again?
Classic Shack burger
Black and white milkshake
SmokeShack burger
Chick'n Shack
If you could order the meal of your dreams, no guilt, no calorie counting and no counting change, what ultimate meal would you order?
All the burgers and every milkshake flavor
Literally everything on the menu
10 orders of fries and all the ice cream treats
A million chicken sandwiches
Could the 'Shroom burger ever be a replacement for a meat burger?
No, but it's really good.
Never in a million years
I actually prefer it.
I'd eat them side by side.

Advertisement

Since you can find Shake Shacks in sports stadiums now, which sport is made way better when eating it?
Baseball
Hockey
Soccer
Football
If you were waiting at the airpot for your flight, what would you order to help pass the time?
A milkshake
Half iced tea, half lemonade and a burger
A full meal
I think just some fries to start.
If you weren't in the mood for a burger, would you order the chicken sandwich?
Probably not
That's the best thing they have.
I'd just get fries.
I'm always in the mood for a burger.

Advertisement

You Got: